Mara: Is It a Good Proxy to Bitcoin?

The cryptocurrency market has evolved significantly over the past decade, and with it, publicly traded companies have emerged as indirect ways to gain exposure to Bitcoin (BTC). One such company is Marathon Digital Holdings (MARA), one of the largest Bitcoin mining firms in the world. Given its strong correlation with Bitcoin’s price movements, many investors view MARA as a potential proxy to Bitcoin. But does it truly serve as a good alternative, or are there crucial differences that investors need to consider?

Understanding MARA and Its Business Model

Marathon Digital Holdings is a Bitcoin mining company that focuses on acquiring and operating high-performance mining hardware. The company generates revenue by mining Bitcoin, which it can either hold as an asset or sell for operational expenses.

MARA’s stock is publicly traded on the NASDAQ, making it accessible to traditional equity investors who may not want to directly invest in Bitcoin due to regulatory concerns, security risks, or the complexities of custody.

However, investing in MARA differs from directly holding Bitcoin in several key ways:

1. MARA’s Correlation with Bitcoin

MARA’s stock price tends to be highly correlated with Bitcoin’s price movements. When Bitcoin’s price rises, MARA often follows, as its mining profits increase. Conversely, when Bitcoin declines, MARA usually experiences a sharper drop due to its leveraged exposure to the asset.

For instance, during Bitcoin’s bull runs in 2020-2021 and again in late 2023-early 2024, MARA saw significant stock price surges. However, it also suffered steep declines in bear markets, often more extreme than Bitcoin’s drawdowns.

2. Leverage and Volatility

MARA’s business model amplifies Bitcoin’s volatility. This is due to:

• Operational Costs: Bitcoin mining is capital-intensive, requiring continuous investment in mining hardware, energy, and infrastructure. When Bitcoin prices drop, MARA still incurs these costs, squeezing profit margins.

• Debt and Dilution: To expand operations, MARA often raises capital through stock issuance or debt, leading to dilution risks for existing shareholders.

• Regulatory Risks: Unlike Bitcoin, which is decentralized, MARA operates within the traditional financial system and is subject to regulatory scrutiny. Changes in mining regulations, energy costs, or environmental policies could negatively impact its business.

3. Performance During Market Cycles

Historically, MARA has outperformed Bitcoin during bull markets but underperformed in bear markets. For example:

• In 2021, Bitcoin surged from ~$30,000 to ~$69,000, and MARA’s stock price increased from around $10 to over $75.

• In the 2022 bear market, Bitcoin declined by ~75%, while MARA plummeted by over 90%.

• In the 2023-2024 recovery, MARA rebounded strongly, but it remained highly volatile compared to Bitcoin.

This high volatility can be a double-edged sword: while MARA can deliver outsized returns when Bitcoin rises, it also exposes investors to extreme downside risk.

4. MARA vs. Bitcoin ETFs

With the approval of Bitcoin spot ETFs, investors now have a more direct way to gain exposure to Bitcoin without owning it directly. Bitcoin ETFs, like BlackRock’s iShares Bitcoin Trust (IBIT) or Grayscale Bitcoin Trust (GBTC), provide a pure-play investment in Bitcoin, avoiding operational and company-specific risks associated with MARA.

MARA, on the other hand, carries additional risks such as:

• Management decisions affecting shareholder value.

• Dependence on Bitcoin mining economics.

• Regulatory uncertainties related to mining and energy consumption.

5. Potential Upside: Why Some Investors Prefer MARA

Despite the risks, some investors prefer MARA over direct Bitcoin exposure due to:

• Leverage Effect: Since MARA’s revenue and profitability are tied to Bitcoin, a significant BTC rally could lead to exponential gains for MARA shareholders.

• Stock Market Accessibility: Some investors prefer to trade equities rather than cryptocurrencies, especially in retirement accounts like IRAs and 401(k)s.

• Potential Business Expansion: If MARA successfully expands operations, increases efficiency, or diversifies revenue streams (e.g., selling mining hardware or offering cloud mining services), it could grow beyond being just a Bitcoin proxy.

Final Verdict: Is MARA a Good Bitcoin Proxy?

MARA can be a high-risk, high-reward alternative to Bitcoin, but it is not a perfect proxy. While it follows Bitcoin’s price trends, its additional exposure to operational costs, leverage, and regulatory risks makes it more volatile. Investors looking for a safer and more direct way to gain Bitcoin exposure might prefer Bitcoin ETFs or even direct Bitcoin ownership.

However, for those willing to take on higher risk for potentially higher rewards, MARA could be a leveraged play on Bitcoin’s future price movements.

Key Takeaways

✅ MARA is highly correlated with Bitcoin but more volatile.

✅ It can outperform Bitcoin during bull markets but underperform in bear markets.

✅ Unlike Bitcoin, MARA faces operational, regulatory, and management risks.

✅ With the rise of Bitcoin spot ETFs, investors have a lower-risk alternative to MARA.

✅ MARA can be a proxy for those seeking leverage on Bitcoin’s price movement.

Ultimately, whether MARA is a good proxy for Bitcoin depends on an investor’s risk tolerance and investment goals. If you seek pure Bitcoin exposure, an ETF or direct ownership is likely the better choice. If you want a leveraged proxy on Bitcoin’s price action, MARA could be a compelling, though risky, option.

Disclaimer: Please kindly do your own due diligence as this is a sharing article and in no means financial advise.

None of us are perfect so let us all be constructive, and create a positive and encouraging learning environment. Warm comments and likes are much appreciated.

Thanks for reading my commentary. Hope it helps!

Stay safe! 😊

$Strategy(MSTR)$