Chagee Adds 15%! Still Confident Holding or Not?

$Chagee Holdings( $Chagee Holdings Limited(CHA)$ )$ $Mixue Group( $MIXUE GROUP(02097)$ )$ $Nayuki Holdings( $NAYUKI HLDGS LTD.(NYKHF)$ )$

Chagee Holdings Limited (CHA) burst onto the Nasdaq scene on Thursday, April 17, 2025, with a 15% surge, closing at $32.20 after peaking at $41.72—a wild 49% intraday spike. Yet, the stock closed below its opening price of $33.75, leaving investors wondering: Is this a signal to hold tight or cash out? Can Chagee mirror Mixue Group’s sustained success, or is it doomed to Nayuki’s downward spiral? Are market expectations overblown, and what’s a fair target price? Let’s dive into the data, comparisons, and analysis to unpack this IPO rollercoaster.

Chagee’s Big Day: Hype Meets Volatility

Chagee’s IPO priced at $28 per share, raising $411 million and pegging its valuation at $5.1 billion. The stock opened at $33.75 and soared to $41.72 before settling at $32.20—a 15% gain but a clear fade from its high. This volatility reflects strong initial demand (the IPO was oversubscribed) tempered by profit-taking or doubts about its staying power.

Here’s the breakdown:

Table: Chagee (CHA) First-Day Snapshot (April 17, 2025)

The tea chain’s fundamentals are robust: revenue nearly tripled to $1.7 billion in 2024, and net income jumped 213% to $344.5 million. With over 6,400 teahouses and plans for 1,000-1,500 more in 2025, Chagee’s growth story is tantalizing—but can it deliver?

Mixue’s Triumph vs. Nayuki’s Tumble: Where Does Chagee Fit?

Mixue Group (2097.HK)

Mixue crushed its Hong Kong IPO in March 2025, rocketing 43% on day one to HKD 290 ($37.10). Its affordable tea and ice cream, paired with a sprawling 46,000-store network, keep it thriving. The key? A low-cost, high-volume model that’s tough to beat in smaller cities.

Nayuki Holdings (2150.HK)

Nayuki’s premium tea play hasn’t aged well. After its 2021 IPO, it’s down 45% over the past year, languishing at HKD 1.71 in April 2025. High prices and a focus on saturated urban markets left it exposed to competition and economic slowdowns.

Chagee’s Position: Chagee leans premium like Nayuki but scales fast like Mixue. Its $5.1 billion valuation demands flawless execution—something Nayuki couldn’t manage. If Chagee nails expansion without sacrificing margins, it could chart Mixue’s course.

Are Market Expectations Too Lofty?

Chagee’s $5.1 billion valuation implies a 3x price-to-sales ratio—steep but not absurd for a growth stock. Bulls point to its 167% revenue surge and 20% net margins (outpacing Starbucks). Bears flag slowing same-store growth and a hefty $1.5 billion marketing tab in 2024. Plus, U.S.-China trade tensions could spook investors, though Chagee insists cross-border trade isn’t its core.

The 15% debut pop shows enthusiasm, but the drop from $41.72 to $32.20 hints at skepticism. Is $5.1 billion too rich? It depends on whether Chagee can keep its growth engine roaring.

Visualizing the Surge:

Target Price: Balancing Risk and Reward

Bullish Case: If Chagee’s expansion pays off and margins hold, $38-$42 is in reach by Q4 2025.
Bearish Case: Trade risks or growth hiccups could pin it at $28-$32.
My View: I’m pegging a near-term target at $36. It’s a 12% upside from $32.20, reflecting solid fundamentals but factoring in volatility and macro uncertainty.

Hold or Fold?

Hold: If you’re long-term bullish, hang on. Set a stop-loss at $29 to guard against a sharper dip.
Sell: Locked in gains above $35? Consider taking profits—volatility could bite.
Buy: Newcomers might wait for $30—a better entry if sentiment sours.

My Stance: I’d hold with caution. Chagee’s got legs, but the market’s jittery. Confidence hinges on its next earnings report.

Your Turn: Chagee’s Fate?

Will Chagee soar like Mixue or fade like Nayuki? What’s your price target? Sound off below—let’s hash it out!

📢 Like, repost, and follow for daily updates on market trends and stock insights.

📝 Disclaimer: This post is for informational purposes only and does not constitute financial advice. Always conduct your own research before making investment decisions.

📌@Daily_Discussion @Tiger_comments @TigerStars @TigerEvents @TigerWire

Chagee Soars on Debut: Take Profits or Hold on Tight?

Chagee went public and surged 15% on Thursday. However, the stock closed lower than its open price. ------------ Can Chagee replicate the surge of Mixue group? Or repeat the down trend like Nayuki? Is the market expectations too high to fulfill? What's your target price for Chagee?

Disclaimer: Investing carries risk. This is not financial advice. The above content should not be regarded as an offer, recommendation, or solicitation on acquiring or disposing of any financial products, any associated discussions, comments, or posts by author or other users should not be considered as such either. It is solely for general information purpose only, which does not consider your own investment objectives, financial situations or needs. TTM assumes no responsibility or warranty for the accuracy and completeness of the information, investors should do their own research and may seek professional advice before investing.