For those of us drawn to income investing, Annaly Capital’s 14.56% dividend yield practically shouts from the rooftop. The figure is mouth-watering, especially in a market still adjusting to rates that may have peaked, but remain historically high. At face value, a payout like that appears to defy gravity. But peel back the layers, and what you find is a highly leveraged structure, interest-rate sensitivity, and a business model that trades sustainability for short-term yield.
Yield's tempting climb, price’s quiet surrender — read the signals
Behind the Yield: Leverage, Not Growth
$Annaly Capital Management(NLY)$ doesn’t own shopping centres or office towers. Instead, it’s a mortgage REIT, or mREIT, that borrows short and invests long—primarily in mortgage-backed securities (MBS) guaranteed by government agencies. The returns aren’t generated from organic revenue growth or operating scale. They’re squeezed from net interest margins and multiplied by leverage. At last count, Annaly had $88.84 billion in debt on just $11.64 billion of market capitalisation, resulting in a staggering debt-to-equity ratio of nearly 679%.
That structure may work beautifully when short-term rates are low and yield curves are steep. But today, the yield curve is still inverted, compressing Annaly’s ability to profit on the spread between borrowing costs and MBS yields. Despite that, the firm recently raised its dividend 7.7%, pushing the payout to $0.70 per share. Admirable? Perhaps. Sustainable? I’m not convinced.
Leverage on leverage — a tower built on tremors
Earnings Under Strain, Margins Shrinking
Let’s talk numbers. Annaly reported trailing twelve-month revenue of $956.14 million, down 54.4% year-over-year. Net income fell even harder—down 73.2%—yet the firm still posted a diluted EPS of $0.92 and maintains a PE ratio of 20.9. Those headline metrics aren’t enough to disguise the underlying squeeze. The current payout ratio is a jaw-dropping 288.04%, far above what I’d consider prudent. In other words, it’s paying out nearly three times what it earns.
Operating margins, while still lofty on paper at 74.6%, are cold comfort when cash flow volatility remains high. $Annaly Capital Management(NLY)$ doesn’t generate earnings in the traditional sense. Instead, it profits from the spread between borrowing and investing, a strategy that worked wonders in a zero-rate world but is now far more exposed. The business lives and dies by monetary policy, not management brilliance.
The Illusion of Book Value Stability
Book value per share sits at $19.02, near the current trading price of $19.28. That might suggest valuation neutrality, but I’d caution against that interpretation. With MBS assets marked to market and heavily influenced by rate expectations, fluctuations in book value can be sharp and unpredictable. A modest shift in long-term Treasury yields could wipe out several quarters’ worth of income or capital overnight.
Investors often assume agency-backed MBS implies safety. But even with government support, the mark-to-market swings are real—and when your portfolio is 7 to 10 times leveraged, even a 1% movement in asset values can lead to violent moves in equity value. Add to that refinancing risks and prepayment volatility, and the model starts to feel more like a derivatives play than a stable income engine.
What the Market Might Be Missing
Here’s a nuance many overlook: the source of Annaly’s yield isn't just leverage—it’s leverage in a distorted rate environment. With the Fed holding rates higher for longer, the firm’s cost of capital has risen substantially, while MBS yields remain rangebound. That has left Annaly with shrinking net interest spreads, just as its dividend commitment has increased. The result is a potential mismatch between expectations and financial capacity.
Another subtlety lies in the beta. Annaly’s five-year monthly beta is 1.32, meaning it moves with greater volatility than the broader market. For a stock marketed as a “safe” income-generating investment, this sort of equity risk feels inconsistent with its positioning. Combine that with a short interest of 2.27%, and you get the sense that a number of institutional investors are betting this isn’t as stable as it seems.
The Trade-Off Between Yield and Flexibility
Let’s not forget cash flow. Annaly is sitting on just $364.2 million in cash, a mere 0.6 per share, while its operating cash flow over the trailing twelve months is $1.46 billion. That might seem robust, but the balance sheet doesn’t offer much cushion. The firm’s current ratio is just 0.46, underscoring limited flexibility in the face of liquidity shocks. A sharp change in repo financing costs, or a material decline in MBS values, could force the company to cut its dividend—or worse, issue equity at dilutive prices.
Why I’m Still Interested—With a Safety Net
So, is Annaly a value trap dressed as a yield king? Not quite. While I’m sceptical of the sustainability of its current payout, I also recognise that some of its risk is already priced in. The stock is trading just above book, with a forward P/E of 6.89 and a long-term dividend yield well above its five-year average. For those willing to accept the volatility—and possibly a dividend reset—the upside from normalising spreads or Fed rate cuts could be meaningful.
In the meantime, this isn’t a set-it-and-forget-it position. I’d size it modestly, watch spreads like a hawk, and treat the dividend as a variable, not a promise. At the right entry point and with eyes wide open, $Annaly Capital Management(NLY)$ can still serve a role in an income-focused portfolio—just not the central one.
From broken balance sheets, bold dividends may still emerge anew
In my view, it’s a tempting play on future rate normalisation rather than a fortress of dependable income. And for investors who understand the dance between yield and risk, that might be more than enough.
@TigerStars @Daily_Discussion @Tiger_comments @Tiger_SG @Tiger_Earnings @TigerClub@ @TigerWire
Comments