The term "green May" in financial markets refers to a May where stock market indices, such as the S&P 500, end the month with positive returns (i.e., the market is "up" or "green"). This is often discussed in the context of market seasonality, particularly the adage "Sell in May and go away," which suggests stocks tend to underperform from May to October. A "green May" challenges this notion, as it indicates positive performance during a month traditionally viewed as weaker. Below, I analyze the historical implications of a green May for financial markets, focusing on the S&P 500, as it’s a widely tracked benchmark, and incorporate relevant context from recent sentiment and data.
Historical Context of a Green May
Seasonality and "Sell in May":
The phrase "Sell in May and go away" stems from historical patterns where stocks often show weaker performance from May through October compared to November through April. However, a green May can signal stronger-than-expected market momentum.
According to a post on X from
@DaanCrypto
on May 13, 2025, May has historically been a "pretty green month" with an average return of over 8%, contrary to the seasonal adage, while June and September tend to be weaker (red months). This suggests a green May may not be an anomaly but part of a broader trend in some years.
Historical Performance After a Green May:
Data from an X post by
@VenkatP1359
on May 31, 2025, indicates that in 7 of the last 10 years when May was positive for the S&P 500, the rest of the year also ended green (i.e., positive returns). Even modest May gains (e.g., +0.5%) were often followed by strong year-end rallies, and "big Mays" (like 2020, 2024, and 2025) preceded significant gains.
For example:
2020: A strong May during the post-COVID recovery led to a robust year-end rally, with the S&P 500 gaining ~16% for the year.
2024: Another green May, followed by positive performance, though specific returns vary by source.
This suggests a green May can act as a bullish signal for the remainder of the year, potentially driven by sustained investor confidence, strong corporate earnings, or favorable economic conditions.
Market Momentum and Sentiment:
A green May often reflects positive investor sentiment, economic recovery signals, or favorable policy developments. For instance, during the 2009 recovery from the financial crisis, Federal Reserve Chair Ben Bernanke’s use of the term "green shoots" to describe nascent economic recovery aligned with positive market performance, including in May.
In 2025, the Schwab Market Open Update noted that despite trade tensions (e.g., U.S.-China tariff concerns), a green May coincided with a forward P/E ratio for the S&P 500 climbing above 21, suggesting investor optimism about future earnings growth, though tempered by concerns about declining corporate profits.
Historical Exceptions:
Not all green Mays guarantee strong annual performance. For instance, a green May in 2001 occurred amidst the dot-com bust, and the year ended negatively due to broader economic challenges. Similarly, external shocks (e.g., geopolitical events or policy shifts) can disrupt the momentum of a green May.
The "Greenspan Put" era (1987–2006) saw the Federal Reserve intervene to stabilize markets during declines, which could amplify positive May performance by ensuring liquidity. However, this also led to concerns about market bubbles, as seen in the late 1990s and 2008 crisis.
Broader Implications
Bullish Signal: A green May often indicates strong market momentum, supported by factors like robust earnings, low interest rates, or positive economic data. Historically, it has correlated with positive year-end performance in many cases, as noted in the 2025 X post.
Sector Performance: A green May may disproportionately benefit certain sectors, such as technology or consumer discretionary, which often drive S&P 500 gains. For example, 2025’s green May was partly attributed to strong Q4 earnings from tech mega-caps.
Policy and Economic Context: The impact of a green May depends on the broader economic environment. For instance, in 2025, trade tensions and declining corporate profits raised concerns, but positive consumer sentiment and expected Federal Reserve remarks suggested continued support for markets.
Green Finance Connection: While "green" in this context refers to positive returns, the rise of green finance (e.g., green bonds, ESG investments) has influenced market dynamics. Investors increasingly favor sustainable assets, which may contribute to positive May performance if green sectors (e.g., renewable energy) outperform. However, no direct historical link ties "green May" to green finance.
Limitations and Considerations
Correlation vs. Causation: A green May does not guarantee a strong year, as external factors (e.g., inflation, geopolitical risks, or Fed policy shifts) can alter trajectories. The 2025 Schwab report highlighted risks like trade tensions and declining profits despite a green May.
Data Variability: Historical data on green Mays is limited to specific indices and timeframes. The X posts focus on the S&P 500 over the last decade, which may not apply universally across markets or longer periods.
Seasonal Myths: The "Sell in May" adage is not always reliable, and a green May can challenge this narrative, as seen in 2025’s reported 8%+ average May returns.
Conclusion
A "green May" in financial markets, particularly for the S&P 500, has historically been a positive signal, often followed by strong year-end performance in 7 of the last 10 years (2015–2025). It reflects investor optimism, economic recovery signals, or policy support (e.g., the Greenspan Put era). However, external factors like trade tensions, inflation, or sector-specific performance can disrupt this trend. In 2025, a green May aligned with high P/E ratios and tech-driven earnings but faced risks from trade policies and profit declines. Investors should view a green May as a potential bullish indicator but remain cautious of broader economic conditions.
Grok states 70% market up. What counters should you buy?
$Palantir Technologies Inc.(PLTR)$
What should you sell?
Comments