$SUPER MICRO COMPUTER INC(SMCI)$
Super Micro Computer’s recent preliminary quarterly results came as a major disappointment to stock market investors. The company's stock plunged by over 16% in after-market trading following the release of their earnings report. This sharp drop has left many—including myself—disappointed, as I had recently upgraded Super Micro stock to a borderline buy. A borderline buy is defined as a recommendation that sits between a hold and a buy, leaning closer to a buy.
Naturally, I'm disheartened by the decline, especially given the optimism I had around this stock in the context of its strong market positioning and growth potential. With this in mind, I’m taking another look at Super Micro following these results to understand the causes behind the stock's significant drop, delve into the specifics of the poor performance, and offer an updated recommendation based on the new information.
Let’s explore why the stock price is falling, whether it is justified, and whether I still think Super Micro is a buy—or if my recommendation needs to be adjusted.
Earnings Results: The Cause of the Decline
To begin, let’s break down the key figures from the company's earnings report, which was released after the U.S. markets closed on April 29, 2025. The company had projected net sales for the current quarter to fall between $5 billion and $6 billion, with a midpoint of $5.5 billion. Unfortunately, the actual results came in significantly below expectations, with net sales of just $4.5 billion to $4.6 billion, or roughly $4.55 billion. This represents a shortfall of about $1 billion, or almost 20%, from the company's initial sales forecast.
Now, let’s take a closer look at the company's net income, or earnings per share (EPS). Super Micro had anticipated EPS to fall between 36 cents and 53 cents, with a midpoint of 44 cents per share. However, the actual EPS came in much lower, around 16 or 17 cents per share, which is just about one-third of the company’s forecasted earnings. Even on a non-GAAP basis—where the company adjusts for one-off items and special circumstances—the result was still disappointing. The company had expected non-GAAP EPS to fall between 46 cents and 62 cents, but it ended up reporting just 30 cents, which is about half of what they had originally forecasted.
Reasons for the Shortfall: Timing or Loss of Sales?
While these numbers are undoubtedly disappointing, Super Micro did provide an explanation for why their results fell so far short of expectations. According to the company, some customers delayed their platform decisions during the third quarter, which shifted sales into the fourth quarter. Essentially, Super Micro had expected a certain volume of sales to occur in the third quarter, but these orders were pushed back due to delays in customer decision-making.
From a strategic standpoint, this appears to be more of a timing issue than a real decline in customer demand. Super Micro’s products are typically ordered in advance, and it’s unlikely that a shift in demand would cause such a sharp drop in revenue unless there was some major issue with the company’s offerings or the market as a whole. However, the magnitude of the shortfall remains concerning, and I can understand why investors have been quick to sell off the stock in response to the disappointing results.
It's also important to note that the dramatic drop in Super Micro's stock price during after-market trading was likely driven by algorithmic trading. These types of trades are pre-programmed to react to earnings results in a set way. For instance, if earnings come in significantly below expectations, the algorithm automatically triggers a sell-off. This type of trading can exacerbate the initial price movement, as machines react quickly to new data. The stock's price could very well recover once more information comes out, including the details provided in the company's conference call with analysts.
While it's easy to get caught up in the immediate reaction to the earnings report, I generally caution against placing too much emphasis on post-earnings price movements, especially when the reaction is as swift and large as it was with Super Micro. As more context is provided and analysts have a chance to absorb the information, the stock's price could stabilize or even recover as investors better understand the reasons behind the results.
The Valuation Perspective: Is Super Micro Still Undervalued?
Before making any adjustments to my recommendation, let’s take a look at the valuation of Super Micro. One of the reasons I had rated the stock as a borderline buy previously was that my discounted cash flow (DCF) model indicated a fair value of $66 per share, compared to the market price at the time of around $36. This implies a significant potential for upside if the company can achieve its projected growth.
It’s worth noting that my DCF models update during trading hours, so the current price will reflect the post-earnings decline tomorrow. For those who follow these models closely, they will see the current market price updated in real-time. However, even though the stock has fallen further since my initial assessment, it’s important to remember that these models are designed to reflect the underlying value of the business over time, and they can fluctuate based on new information.
Another way to assess Super Micro’s valuation is by looking at its forward price-to-earnings (P/E) ratio. According to data from finchhat.io, the company’s forward P/E ratio stands at 12.44. This is within the range of the company’s historical valuation going back to 2021, which is when they had a lower level of demand for their products and services. However, Super Micro is now operating in a much stronger position, particularly due to the rapid growth of artificial intelligence (AI) and the accompanying demand for liquid cooling solutions in AI-optimized data centers.
Conclusion
After reviewing the earnings report, the company’s explanations, and the overall market reaction, I’m maintaining my stance on Super Micro as a borderline buy. Despite the disappointing earnings results, I still believe that the stock is undervalued, especially given the company’s strong position in a growing market for AI infrastructure. The timing issue that Super Micro cited for the revenue shortfall is concerning but doesn’t fundamentally alter my long-term view on the company. The market for AI and data centers is booming, and Super Micro’s products are in high demand.
However, I am still cautious due to the risks associated with the company’s management transparency and the financial reporting issues that have plagued Super Micro in recent years. These risks remain elevated, and they are a key factor in why I’m not upgrading the stock to a full buy. Until there’s more certainty around the company’s management practices and its ability to meet financial reporting deadlines, I’m sticking with the borderline buy rating.
In conclusion, while the earnings report was disappointing and the stock price reaction is understandable, I believe that Super Micro is still undervalued and positioned in a high-growth market. For those willing to accept the associated risks, the stock remains an attractive, albeit cautious, investment at this time.
Disclaimer: I want to make it clear that I am not a financial advisor, and nothing I say is intended to be a recommendation to buy or sell any financial instrument. Additionally, it's important to remember that there are no guarantees or certainties in trading or investing, and you should never invest money that you can't afford to lose.
@Daily_Discussion @TigerPM @TigerObserver @Tiger_comments @TigerClub
Comments