The AI revolution has been one of the biggest drivers of the stock market over the past few years. But what if the technology that is making companies more productive also creates risks for the wider economy?
That is an important question raised by Fed Chair Kevin Warsh on November 16, when he outlined three possible scenarios for how artificial intelligence and superintelligence could reshape the US economy.
His comments came during another difficult session for technology stocks. $Invesco QQQ(QQQ)$ dropped 2.67%, while $SPDR S&P 500 ETF Trust(SPY)$ declined 1.91%.
Warsh was not predicting which scenario would happen, and his remarks should not be treated as an explanation for the market decline.
However, I think his three scenarios highlight something investors should pay more attention to: AI’s economic success and AI stocks’ investment returns are not necessarily the same thing.
1. Scenario One: AI creates a productivity boom
This is the outcome most investors are hoping for.
AI allows businesses to automate repetitive tasks, improve efficiency and produce more without proportionately increasing costs.
For companies, this could mean:
• Higher operating margins.
• Lower labour costs.
• Faster product development.
• Increased productivity.
• Stronger earnings growth.
This would potentially benefit companies across multiple industries, not just technology.
$NVIDIA(NVDA)$ and other semiconductor companies could benefit from continued demand for computing power. $Microsoft(MSFT)$ , $Amazon.com(AMZN)$ and $Alphabet(GOOGL)$ could expand their cloud and AI businesses.
More importantly, companies outside the technology sector could also become more profitable by adopting AI.
If productivity gains translate into sustainable earnings growth, current technology valuations may become easier to justify.
2. Scenario Two: AI succeeds, but employment suffers
This is where things become more complicated.
Imagine businesses successfully integrating AI into their operations.
They become more efficient, reduce costs and increase output. However, they also need fewer employees to perform certain tasks.
Corporate profits could improve even as some workers face unemployment or pressure on wages.
This creates a potential economic imbalance.
Businesses may benefit from automation, but households could experience weaker income growth and reduced spending power.
That matters because consumer spending is a major part of the US economy.
If employment conditions deteriorate significantly, weaker consumption could eventually affect corporate revenue across many sectors.
For investors, this creates an unusual situation: some companies could report stronger margins while the broader economy becomes less healthy.
This is why I would not automatically assume that rising AI productivity translates into higher stock prices for every company.
3. Scenario Three: AI investment fails to deliver the expected returns
This is the scenario I would pay closest attention to from an investment perspective.
Technology companies have committed enormous amounts of money to AI infrastructure.
Data centres, advanced GPUs, networking equipment and electricity capacity all require substantial capital investment.
The market has rewarded many companies based on expectations that this spending will eventually produce significant financial returns.
But what happens if the returns disappoint?
Cloud providers could slow capital expenditure. AI developers could struggle to generate sufficient revenue. Investors could begin questioning whether the infrastructure being built today will generate enough cash flow tomorrow.
The consequences could be significant.
Semiconductor companies might face slower demand growth. Data-centre operators could experience valuation pressure. Software companies might struggle to justify premium multiples.
Even companies reporting positive earnings could see their share prices fall if future expectations are revised downward.
This is the important distinction between technological progress and investment returns.
AI can become increasingly powerful without every company investing in it becoming more profitable.
4. Why QQQ could be particularly sensitive
QQQ provides exposure to some of the largest technology and growth companies in the US market.
Many of these businesses are directly or indirectly connected to AI spending.
That creates considerable upside potential, but it also means the index can become sensitive to changes in expectations.
There are three things I would watch:
AI capital expenditure
Are Microsoft, Amazon, Google and Meta generating enough returns to justify their enormous infrastructure spending?
If spending continues increasing but revenue growth does not keep pace, investors may become concerned.
Earnings growth
Are AI investments translating into better operating margins and free cash flow?
Revenue growth alone is not enough. Investors eventually want to see financial returns.
Valuations
How much future growth is already reflected in share prices?
When valuations are high, even relatively small disappointments can trigger significant corrections.
5. How I would position after QQQ’s pullback
I would not automatically buy the dip, but I would not assume that one difficult trading session signals the end of the AI bull market either.
My approach would be to separate long-term opportunities from short-term market sentiment.
For long-term investors, gradual purchases of QQQ could help manage the risk of entering the market at an unfavourable price.
For investors already heavily exposed to technology stocks, reviewing portfolio concentration would be sensible. Holding several AI-related stocks does not necessarily provide much diversification if they all depend on the same capital expenditure cycle.
For more cautious investors, keeping some cash available provides flexibility if valuations fall further.
I would also watch whether QQQ stabilises alongside other major technology stocks. A recovery supported by improving market breadth would be more encouraging than a rebound driven by only a handful of large companies.
6. My biggest takeaway
Of Warsh’s three scenarios, I think the third deserves particular attention from investors because it directly challenges the financial assumptions behind the AI rally.
However, the second scenario should not be ignored.
If AI creates significant productivity gains but employment and household spending weaken, the benefits may not be distributed evenly across the economy.
Ultimately, investors need to consider both sides of the equation.
AI could make businesses more efficient, create entirely new industries and improve economic productivity. But the companies that benefit most from this transformation may not necessarily be the ones receiving the highest valuations today.
My view: I remain positive about AI over the long term, but I would become increasingly selective about valuations and business fundamentals.
The biggest risk is not necessarily that AI fails. It is that investors pay for an optimistic future that takes much longer to arrive than expected.
For QQQ, the next stage of the AI rally will depend less on exciting announcements and more on whether technology companies can turn their enormous investments into sustainable earnings and cash flow.
For discussion purposes only. Not financial advice.
Comments