To The Moon

Stagflation, a challenging economic environment characterized by stagnant economic growth, high inflation, and typically high unemployment, generally poses significant headwinds for the stock market.

Why Recent Economic Data Suggest Potential Stagflation?

The combination of the unexpected economic contraction (negative GDP growth) in Q1 alongside inflation metrics that accelerated on a quarterly basis and remain well above the Fed's target is the core reason for rising stagflation concerns.

Weakening manufacturing activity with simultaneously rising price pressures, coupled with early signs of a cooling labor market, adds to the picture. Analysts are specifically using the term "stagflation warning shot" in response to this recent mix of data.

Below is a summary of the most recent U.S. economic data that analysts are pointing to when discussing potential stagflation risks:

Summary of Most Recent U.S. Economic data

Slowing Economic Growth (The 'Stag' part)

Q1 2025 GDP Contraction: The Bureau of Economic Analysis (BEA) reported on April 30, 2025, that Real Gross Domestic Product (GDP) decreased at an annual rate of 0.3% in the first quarter of 2025. This was a sharp downturn from the 2.4% growth in Q4 2024 and significantly missed forecasts (which were around +0.2%). While partially attributed to a surge in imports (possibly related to tariff anticipation) and a drop in government spending, it signals a notable slowdown in economic momentum.  

Weak Manufacturing PMIs (April 2025): The ISM Manufacturing PMI released on May 1 fell further into contraction territory at 48.7 (down from 49.0 in March). Critically, the report showed new orders contracting and production contracting at a faster rate.  

The S&P Global US Manufacturing PMI (final reading May 1) was 50.2, indicating only marginal expansion and revised down from the preliminary estimate. Output declined for a second month, and new export orders fell sharply, with tariffs cited as a factor.

Persistent Inflation (The 'flation' part)

Elevated Q1 Inflation Metrics (GDP Report): While monthly inflation moderated slightly in March, the GDP report for Q1 revealed an acceleration in key quarterly price measures compared to Q4 2024: The PCE price index increased at a 3.6% annualized rate in Q1 (up from 2.4% in Q4).

The Core PCE price index (excluding food and energy, the Fed's preferred gauge) increased at a 3.5% rate in Q1 (up from 2.6% in Q4).

Sticky March Inflation (Monthly): The monthly PCE report (released April 30) showed year-over-year Core PCE inflation at 2.6% in March. While down slightly from February (2.8%) and matching expectations, it remains stubbornly above the Federal Reserve's 2% target. Headline PCE was 2.3% YoY.  

High Manufacturing Prices Paid (April 2025): The April ISM Manufacturing PMI report showed the Prices Index remained highly elevated at 69.8, indicating input costs continued to rise rapidly for manufacturers. S&P Global also noted sharply rising input costs and the fastest rise in factory selling prices since early 2023.

Signs of Labor Market Cooling (Potentially contributing to 'Stag')

March Unemployment: The unemployment rate ticked up to 4.2% in March (from 4.1% in February). (April data is expected later today, May 2nd).  

Weak Private Payrolls (April ADP): The ADP private employment report released April 30 showed only 62,000 jobs added in April, far below expectations (~160,000) and the weakest reading since early 2021.

Rising Jobless Claims: Weekly initial unemployment claims have been trending higher in recent weeks.  

Why These Suggests Potential Stagflation

Overall Market Performance

Negative Pressure: Stagflation is broadly considered negative for overall stock market returns. Corporate profits get squeezed from two sides: stagnant growth reduces sales revenue, while high inflation increases operating costs (materials, energy, wages). This pressure on earnings often leads to lower stock prices.  

Increased Volatility: The economic uncertainty and policy challenges associated with stagflation typically lead to higher market volatility and risk aversion among investors.

If we have noticed how the market have been trading in recent weeks, there have been volatile trading with selling off and also investors buying pressure, this could be due to the fear and greed index at neutral, meaning that investors are divided into believing the market would rally and on the other hand, there is another group of thoughts that market might experience another bout of selloffs.

If we looked at how the VIX had dropped from its high of 40s to below 30s, this signal that market is beginning to look forward to a rally, but do remember that the risk is not over yet, as it is still near the 25 level, which could signal another rise to a high VIX if market experience weaker economic data e.g. high unemployment rate.

Historical Precedent: The most notable period of stagflation in the U.S. was during the 1970s and early 1980s. During this time, the stock market delivered poor real (inflation-adjusted) returns; the S&P 500 lost nearly half its value in real terms over the decade.

During the two stagflationary episodes of the 1970s, the stock market – as defined by the S&P 500 index (US 500) – failed to beat inflation.

Impact on Corporate Earnings and Valuations

Margin Squeeze: Companies struggle to maintain profit margins as costs rise faster than they can increase prices, especially when demand is weak due to stagnant growth.  

Valuation Compression: High inflation often leads central banks (like the Federal Reserve) to raise interest rates. Higher rates increase borrowing costs for companies and reduce the present value of future earnings, which tends to lower stock valuations, particularly for growth stocks. The Fed faces a dilemma, as raising rates to fight inflation can worsen the economic stagnation.  

Investor Sentiment

Risk Aversion: Uncertainty about economic prospects and corporate profitability often leads investors to reduce risk, selling stocks and moving towards assets perceived as safer.

Sector Performance Variations

While the broad market tends to struggle, performance often varies significantly by sector:

Sectors Likely to Underperform: Consumer Discretionary: Hit hard by reduced consumer spending power due to inflation and unemployment.

Technology/Growth Stocks: Sensitive to higher interest rates (which reduce the value of future earnings) and potential cuts in business investment. High-valuation stocks are particularly vulnerable.  

We are still seeing strong performance from the Technology sectors but this does not seem to relate to what is really happening in the market now, this could be due to the hope of Fed cutting the interest rate by one percentage point.

Financials: May suffer from lower loan demand and potentially higher loan defaults in a stagnant economy.  

Industrials: Often sensitive to overall economic activity, which is weak during stagflation. Sectors Likely to Be More Resilient or Outperform: Energy & Commodities: Often perform well, particularly if rising energy and commodity prices are a key driver of the inflation. Companies producing these raw materials can benefit from higher prices.  

Consumer Staples: Companies selling essential goods (food, beverages, household products) tend to see more stable demand regardless of economic conditions.  

Healthcare: Demand for healthcare services tends to be relatively stable.  

Utilities: Provide essential services and often have regulated pricing structures that may offer some inflation protection.  

Value Stocks: Companies trading at lower valuations with stable earnings may hold up better than expensive growth stocks.

Impact on Other Investments

Bonds: Traditional fixed-rate bonds typically perform poorly during stagflation because inflation erodes the real value of their fixed payments, and rising interest rates push bond prices down. Inflation-linked bonds (like TIPS) may offer some protection.  

Real Assets: Assets like gold, commodities, and potentially real estate (especially if financed with fixed-rate debt) have historically performed relatively well during stagflation as hedges against inflation.  

Stocks and ETFs We Can Look At

Here are some areas and specific examples of stocks and ETFs investors might look into during stagflation:

1. Defensive Sectors (Stable Demand)  

Why: Companies in these sectors provide essential goods and services, meaning demand tends to remain relatively stable even during economic downturns. They may also have better pricing power to pass on inflation costs.  

Sector ETFs: $Consumer Staples Select Sector SPDR Fund(XLP)$ : Tracks major U.S. consumer staples companies (food, beverages, household products).  

$Health Care Select Sector SPDR Fund(XLV)$ : Tracks major U.S. healthcare companies (pharma, providers, equipment).  

$Utilities Select Sector SPDR Fund(XLU)$ : Tracks major U.S. utility companies.  

Example Stocks (Illustrative Large-Caps): $Procter & Gamble(PG)$ - Consumer Staples  

$Coca-Cola(KO)$ / PepsiCo (PEP) - Consumer Staples Johnson & Johnson (JNJ) - Healthcare  

UnitedHealth Group (UNH) - Healthcare  

NextEra Energy (NEE) - Utilities  

2. Inflation Beneficiaries & Hedges

Why: Companies in these sectors may benefit directly from rising commodity prices, or the underlying assets (like gold) act as a store of value during inflation and uncertainty.

Sector/Commodity ETFs: $Energy Select Sector SPDR Fund(XLE)$ Tracks major U.S. energy companies. Energy often performs well when inflation is driven by energy costs.  

Materials Select Sector SPDR Fund (XLB): Tracks companies involved in producing raw materials.  

SPDR Gold Shares (GLD) / iShares Gold Trust (IAU): Track the price of physical gold, a traditional safe-haven asset during uncertainty and inflation.  

Invesco DB Commodity Index Tracking Fund (DBC): Provides broad exposure to various commodities futures.  

Example Stocks (Illustrative Large-Caps): ExxonMobil (XOM) / Chevron (CVX) - Energy

Summary

Stagflation presents a difficult environment for stock market investors. It generally leads to lower overall returns, higher volatility, and a shift in leadership away from growth and cyclical stocks towards more defensive sectors and those benefiting directly from inflation, like energy and commodities.

Appreciate if you could share your thoughts in the comment section whether you think consumer cyclical stocks is one defensive way to prepare us if U.S. goes into stagflation.

@TigerStars @Daily_Discussion @Tiger_Earnings @TigerWire appreciate if you could feature this article so that fellow tiger would benefit from my investing and trading thoughts.

Disclaimer: The analysis and result presented does not recommend or suggest any investing in the said stock. This is purely for Analysis.