To The Moon

$Tesla Motors(TSLA)$

In the world of equity markets, few companies ignite as much debate — or as much passion — as Tesla, Inc. The electric vehicle and clean energy giant has been one of the defining corporate stories of the 21st century, transforming an entire industry, making a generational entrepreneur out of Elon Musk, and turning early shareholders into multi-millionaires.

But with that outsize success has come equally outsize scrutiny. Today, as Tesla’s stock trades more than 35% below its all-time highs, after a year of slowing growth, contracting margins, and intensifying competitive pressures, investors find themselves once again questioning whether the stock represents a visionary bet on the future — or a signal to cut and run.

The tension between Tesla’s long-term potential and its short-term struggles is palpable. In one camp, bullish investors argue that recent weakness offers a rare opportunity to accumulate shares in one of the world’s most innovative companies at a relative discount. In the other, skeptics warn that the signs of strain — falling deliveries, price cuts, and an increasingly distracted CEO — point to deeper structural challenges.

The question has taken on added urgency in recent weeks as investors digest disappointing delivery numbers, signs of margin erosion, and growing competition from both legacy automakers and aggressive Chinese entrants. At the same time, new initiatives in autonomy, energy storage, and artificial intelligence keep the bull case alive.

To help investors weigh their next move, this analysis examines Tesla’s current crossroads, the near-term risks and opportunities, lessons from its tumultuous history, how the market is positioning, and whether today’s Tesla remains the audacious, world-changing investment of a decade ago — or whether the red flags now outweigh the vision.

Tesla At A Crossroads

It is no exaggeration to say that Tesla is standing at one of the most consequential junctures in its history.

For years, Tesla enjoyed an open field. As the first automaker to prove that electric vehicles could be desirable, profitable, and scalable, it captured the lion’s share of EV market share in the U.S. and built a powerful global brand. From 2015 through 2021, Tesla grew deliveries at an average annual rate of over 50%, while margins improved and free cash flow turned consistently positive.

But 2024 and early 2025 have revealed cracks in the story. Most recently, Tesla reported quarterly vehicle deliveries of approximately 443,956 units, missing Wall Street’s consensus forecasts. Analysts pointed to softer-than-expected demand in China — where Tesla faces aggressive competition from BYD and others — and slower growth in Europe as consumers balk at high EV prices and charging limitations.

Margins, meanwhile, have come under pressure. The company’s operating margin dropped to 7.2%, a steep decline from over 14% at its pandemic-era peak. Management attributed this erosion to a deliberate strategy of cutting prices to maintain volume — a move aimed at warding off competitors but which has inevitably weighed on profitability.

Adding to concerns are regulatory headwinds and questions around Musk’s divided focus. Tesla remains under scrutiny for its Autopilot and Full Self-Driving software, which regulators have called into question after several high-profile accidents. Meanwhile, Elon Musk — once the company’s singular, driving force — now splits his time among Tesla, SpaceX, X (formerly Twitter), and his nascent AI and brain-computer interface ventures.

And yet, even at this crossroads, Tesla retains unique advantages. Its global Supercharger network, vertically integrated battery supply chain, and early-mover brand equity remain unmatched. It is still the only large-scale EV manufacturer that is consistently profitable, and its energy storage and AI segments — while still modest contributors — are growing fast.

More Pain Ahead Or A Golden Ticket Opportunity?

The conflicting signals in Tesla’s recent performance have left investors divided over whether the company’s stock represents a looming trap or a compelling chance to own a transformational business at a discount.

The bearish case is straightforward. EV adoption growth has slowed from its torrid early pace, particularly as the pool of early adopters has largely been converted. Mainstream consumers remain price-sensitive, and Tesla’s aggressive price cuts may indicate flagging demand rather than strategic brilliance. Meanwhile, competitors — from Ford’s F-150 Lightning to Volkswagen’s ID series to an army of Chinese manufacturers — are quickly closing the technological and cost gap.

Skeptics also point out that Tesla’s valuation remains demanding. Even after a steep pullback, Tesla trades at a forward price-to-earnings multiple over 50x, a premium not just to traditional automakers but also to many technology companies. The stock is still priced for significant growth — and if growth continues to slow, the valuation could compress further.

But the bull case remains compelling. Tesla is still growing revenues at a double-digit clip, despite the macro headwinds. Its energy storage and solar businesses are expanding at much faster rates, and its artificial intelligence work — particularly around autonomous driving and robotics — could unlock entirely new, high-margin revenue streams in the future.

Bulls argue that Tesla is playing the long game: sacrificing short-term profits to entrench its dominance, expand its fleet, and gather the data needed to perfect autonomy. They also note that the company’s track record of delivering — even through adversity — should not be underestimated.

Historical Lessons From The Past

Indeed, Tesla’s history is a testament to its resilience and its founder’s relentless ambition.

Few companies have endured more doubters — or more near-death experiences. In 2008, the company narrowly avoided bankruptcy during the global financial crisis, rescued by emergency financing just before running out of cash. In 2017, during the infamous “production hell” of the Model 3 launch, critics dismissed Tesla as overhyped and underdelivering.

In each instance, the company not only survived but emerged stronger. The Model 3 became the world’s best-selling EV, and by 2020 Tesla was generating sustained profits and free cash flow. Investors who stuck with Tesla through those turbulent years saw staggering returns: a 10,000%+ gain over the past decade.

However, history also offers a cautionary note. Tesla’s stock has always been volatile, often dropping 30–50% during periods of doubt before recovering. Investors who panicked during those dips often sold too early, while those who stayed the course or averaged in were richly rewarded.

The lesson: Tesla is inherently speculative — but speculation, when combined with vision and execution, can be extraordinarily rewarding over time.

Market Sentiment: Divided But Not Panicked

Today, market sentiment reflects this duality.

On Wall Street, analysts remain cautious but not overtly bearish. According to FactSet, roughly 45% of analysts rate the stock “Buy” or “Overweight,” 35% “Hold,” and 20% “Sell.” The median price target suggests moderate upside, but with a wide range of estimates — from as low as $100 per share to over $300.

Institutional investors have trimmed holdings modestly over the past two quarters, but retail enthusiasm remains robust. Tesla remains one of the most widely owned and most actively traded stocks on platforms like Robinhood and Fidelity.

Options markets reflect a cautious but balanced outlook, with implied volatility elevated and put-to-call ratios near historical averages. The market seems to be bracing for more turbulence but not betting heavily on either disaster or a sharp rebound.

Social sentiment remains more polarized. Tesla’s fanbase on social media continues to defend the company vociferously, while critics point to Musk’s sometimes erratic behavior and the company’s recent stumbles as evidence that the stock’s best days are behind it.

Visionary Investment Or Red Flag?

Ultimately, the debate comes down to this: is Tesla still the visionary investment that disrupts industries, or does its current trajectory and valuation flash a red flag?

Those who believe in the vision point not just to EVs but to the company’s broader ambitions: full autonomy, robotaxi fleets, humanoid robots, and a decarbonized energy grid powered by solar and batteries. If even a fraction of these initiatives succeed, the upside could be immense.

Detractors counter that such a future is far from guaranteed — and may already be more than fully priced into the stock. They argue that Tesla has transitioned from scrappy innovator to incumbent, facing the inevitable slowdown and margin compression that comes with maturity.

Both sides agree on one thing: Tesla is speculative. But speculation is not inherently bad — it simply demands an honest assessment of risk tolerance, time horizon, and conviction in the underlying thesis.

Conclusion

Tesla today stands at a pivotal moment in its remarkable journey. Its stock remains expensive relative to traditional automakers, but cheaper than its own historical multiples. Its growth is slowing, but its innovation engine is still running.

Here are the key takeaways for investors:

1. Tesla is speculative by nature. Its stock has always priced in future potential rather than just current earnings. That makes it volatile — and risky.

2. Valuation is still demanding. Even after its pullback, Tesla trades at a premium to most peers. Investors must believe in long-term growth and margin expansion to justify the price.

3. Execution matters. Delivering on autonomy, scaling energy, and maintaining EV leadership are crucial to the bull case.

4. Sentiment is divided. Wall Street and Main Street both reflect cautious optimism, but not euphoria — suggesting room for upside if fundamentals improve.

5. Know your risk tolerance. Tesla is not for the faint of heart. Long-term believers may see dips as buying opportunities, while more conservative investors may prefer to wait for greater clarity.

At the end of the day, Tesla remains one of the most fascinating and debated companies of our time. Whether it proves to be a bold bet on the future or a blatant bail signal will depend on how it navigates its current crossroads. Investors must weigh the risks and opportunities carefully — and decide whether they have the conviction to stay the course.

Disclaimer: I want to make it clear that I am not a financial advisor, and nothing I say is intended to be a recommendation to buy or sell any financial instrument. Additionally, it's important to remember that there are no guarantees or certainties in trading or investing, and you should never invest money that you can't afford to lose.

@Daily_Discussion @TigerPM @TigerObserver @Tiger_comments @TigerClub