To The Moon

$SUPER MICRO COMPUTER INC(SMCI)$

Super Micro Stock Soars Over 100% in 2025 — But Is It Still a Buy Ahead of Earnings?

After a blistering start to 2025, shares of Super Micro Computer, Inc. (SMCI) have surged more than 100% year-to-date—an exceptional run that has rewarded early investors handsomely. This surge places Super Micro among the top-performing stocks in the AI hardware and server space. Earlier this year, I rated the stock a Buy and reaffirmed that stance in late May. That recommendation has more than paid off, and with months still left in the year, the performance has already exceeded expectations.

Alongside other strong performers I highlighted—such as Uber, which continues to deliver outstanding returns—Super Micro has proven to be one of my most successful calls for 2025. That said, the question investors are asking now is: Should you buy Super Micro before it reports earnings on August 5th? In this article, I’ll walk you through the key themes ahead of earnings, share my updated valuation, and offer an updated investment rating.

Earnings Preview: What to Watch from Super Micro

As we look toward Super Micro’s upcoming earnings report, it’s helpful to review the company’s last update on May 6. During that quarter, management acknowledged that several enterprise clients had postponed major orders amid macro uncertainty. Much of this hesitation was triggered by the reintroduction of U.S. trade tariffs under former President Donald Trump. The abrupt policy changes caused corporate buyers to hit pause—unsure whether tariffs would rise, fall, or vanish entirely.

The consequence was widespread inertia. Businesses were reluctant to commit to hardware purchases while tariff guidelines shifted almost weekly. As a result, Super Micro, along with many other companies, experienced delays in customer decision-making, which weighed on short-term visibility.

Tariff Clarity Returns: A Tailwind for Super Micro

Since that last earnings update, the trade landscape has become clearer. The U.S. has formalized new agreements with several key trading partners, including the European Union and Japan. In both cases, a standardized 15% tariff was introduced on select imports—most notably automobiles. While these tariffs are still elevated compared to pre-2020 levels, the consistency they now offer is welcome news for business planning.

The broader takeaway for investors is that the chaotic tariff whiplash that plagued decision-making earlier this year has eased. Companies can now better forecast costs, assess pricing strategy, and resume hardware procurement plans—a dynamic that should benefit Super Micro in the coming quarter.

Super Micro’s management indicated that delayed commitments are expected to materialize in the June and September quarters, reinforcing their confidence in the company’s long-term targets. While near-term risks tied to macro uncertainty remain, the improving clarity in trade policy offers some relief to operating forecasts.

Cash Flow Headwinds: Understanding the Inventory-Receivables Mismatch

As of March 31, Super Micro reported approximately $2.5 billion in cash and equivalents, with an equivalent amount in bank debt and convertible notes. For a company that just a couple of years ago was navigating a significant liquidity crunch, this is a marked improvement.

The previous cash flow challenges stemmed not from operational weakness but rather from the nature of the business model. Super Micro, as a hardware manufacturer, must often pay suppliers upfront for inventory while collecting payments on longer timelines from customers—many of whom wield greater negotiating power.

This created a mismatch between cash outflows and inflows, resulting in several quarters of negative operating cash flow. While this pattern is typical for fast-growing hardware businesses, investor concern was amplified at the time due to accounting-related transparency issues. The company was under scrutiny for discrepancies in its financial statements and a lack of clarity in management's communication with auditors.

With many of these concerns now resolved—and cash reserves replenished—the market has responded with enthusiasm. The 100%+ rise in the stock price this year reflects renewed confidence in the company’s operational trajectory and financial discipline.

Valuation Update: From Undervalued to Approaching Stretch Territory

When I initially rated Super Micro a Buy, it was trading at deeply discounted levels. Today, that dynamic has shifted. The stock is now trading above $60 per share, and my proprietary discounted cash flow (DCF) model pegs the intrinsic value at $51 per share.

Additionally, data from Fiscal.ai (formerly Finch) shows that the company is now trading at a forward price-to-earnings ratio of 25—its highest level in recent history. To put that in context, Super Micro’s forward PE averaged between 8 to 12 for much of the last decade (excluding the past two years). That multiple compression was historically driven by lower visibility and margin constraints, both of which have since improved but are not without their risks.

Given the recent rally, the valuation is now no longer attractive for new entrants. What was once an undervalued gem has now entered territory that could be considered fairly valued—or even moderately overvalued—heading into earnings.

Investment Verdict (August 2025): Hold

Based on current fundamentals, recent valuation re-rating, and the pending earnings announcement, I am downgrading Super Micro from a Buy to a Hold.

For investors who followed my original recommendation earlier this year, this is a prime opportunity to take partial profits. That said, I do not believe there’s an urgent reason to sell the entire position. The company’s longer-term outlook remains solid, and for long-term holders with a multi-year horizon, the upside potential still exists—albeit more muted than before.

However, for those considering new purchases ahead of earnings, I would urge caution. At current valuations, Super Micro is priced for perfection, and any disappointment in the next report could result in significant short-term volatility.

Key Takeaways

1. Stock Performance: Super Micro shares are up over 100% year-to-date, making it one of the standout performers of 2025.

2. Earnings Outlook: Investors should closely monitor whether delayed customer commitments indeed materialize in the June and September quarters.

3. Tariff Environment: While elevated tariffs remain, the increased clarity provides a more stable backdrop for enterprise buying decisions.

4. Valuation Concerns: The stock is trading at a 25x forward PE—well above its historical range—and appears fully valued relative to intrinsic value models.

5. Investment Rating: I am downgrading the stock to Hold. Current shareholders should consider locking in gains, while new investors may want to wait for a better entry point after earnings volatility.

Super Micro remains a high-quality name in the AI infrastructure and server solutions space. Its long-term prospects remain intact, but after an exceptional rally, the easy gains may be behind us—for now.