To The Moon

1️⃣ YTD Performance (as of Dec 4 close)

💡 Key Insight: All three are at or near historic highs, but 🔥 driving logic and 💰 valuation levels show significant divergence.

2️⃣ Multi-Dimensional Analysis

🔍 Differences in Driving Factors

$U.S. Steel(X)$ - Event-Driven

• 🚀 Acquisition Premium Logic: Post-Nippon Steel acquisition, 200+ operational efficiency measures + $14B capital investment ($11B before 2028) form core catalyst

• 🏭 Capacity Restart: Granite City blast furnace restart adds 400 jobs, directly responding to demand growth

• ⚠️ Political Risk: United Steelworkers opposition persists; "golden share" mechanism creates governance uncertainty

🔥 $VanEck Steel ETF(SLX)$ - Concentrated Industry Beta

• 🌍 Global Steel Supply Chain: 75% concentrated in iron ore miners (淡水河谷(VALE) , 力拓(RIO) ) and steel producers, directly capturing industry cyclicality

• ⚠️ Technical Overbought: RSI(6) at 81.78, KDJ slowing at highs, but MACD golden cross strengthening—showing momentum and risk coexist

• 💰 Fund Flow: $5.556M net inflow on Dec 3, but volume ratio only 0.52—turnover turning cautious

⚖️ $SPDR S&P Metals & Mining ETF(XME)$ - Diversified Metals Basket

• 📊 Steel Weight 35.82%: Significantly lower than SLX; includes coal (18.58%), 黄金ETF−SPDR(GLD) (14.98%), aluminum (9.5%) and more

• 🛡️ Hedging Characteristics: When steel pulls back, precious metals and coal may provide buffer—suitable for risk-adjusted allocation

• 🏢 Institutional Preference: 摩根士丹利(MS) (8.62%), Raymond James (7.60%) concentrated holdings show long-term confidence

📊 Valuation and Risk Matrix

🎯 Comprehensive Key Judgment: $U.S. Steel(X)$ 's valuation may have priced in excessive optimism; $VanEck Steel ETF(SLX)$ is in a technically high-risk zone; $SPDR S&P Metals & Mining ETF(XME)$ is relatively balanced.

📈 Deep Dive into Technical Signals

$U.S. Steel(X)$

• 📍 Support Logic: $43.77 (June low) is the "price anchor before acquisition narrative confirmation"—breaking below undermines narrative logic

• 🚧 Resistance Significance: $54.91 is not just 52-week high but an extension of 2021 cycle top—breaching requires incremental catalysts beyond M&A expectations

🔥 VanEckSteelETF(SLX)

• 📊 MACD Health: Histogram 0.88 and expanding—shows momentum strong but acceleration slowing; beware "momentum exhaustion divergence"

• ⚠️ RSI Implications: 81.78 overbought ≠ bearish; watch for price making new highs while RSI fails to—that's true top divergence

• 🎢 KDJ Slowing: In strong trends, KDJ>80 can persist for weeks—key is if D-value turns; currently D 80.84 still rising

⚖️ $SPDR S&P Metals & Mining ETF(XME)$

• 📍 Relative Position: 10% below high = "non-overbought status"—provides safety margin for first pullback

• 📉 Volatility Profile: Multi-metals hedging creates lower VIX correlation vs SLX—suitable for low-vol preference

3️⃣ ETF Helper Summary & Risk Warnings

💎 Core Conclusions

🚨 Maximum Risk Warning

If global manufacturing PMI stays below 50 for two consecutive months in 2026, all cyclicals face indiscriminate selling. Please assess your risk tolerance 💪

🎯 Allocation Philosophy Reference

• ⏰ Don't chase at cycle tops, watch support: All three at highs—patiently wait for 3-5% healthy pullback before re-evaluating

• 📊 Narrow ETFs need timing, broad ETFs suit DCA: SLX requires technical assistance; XME fits dollar-cost averaging

• 🍽️ Individual stocks are seasoning, ETFs are main course: X can flavor portfolios, but core positions belong in XME or SLX

👨‍🏫 ETF Helper's Final Advice

Steel is a quintessential high-cyclical, high-volatility, policy-sensitive sector. Current new highs reflect Beta moves, not Alpha opportunities. Investors should build a "watchlist-wait for pullback-scale in-verify-adjust" framework—not chase instant moves 🏃‍♂️

📌 Data Timeliness: Analysis based on early-December 2025 market data; technical indicators change daily—please track continuously.

For SG users only, 🏦 Open a CBA today and enjoy privileges of up to SGD 20,000 in trading limit with 0 commission. Trade SG, HK, US stocks as well as ETFs unlimitedly!

Complete your first Cash Boost Account trade with a trade amount of ≥ SGD 1000* to get SGD 688 stock vouchers*! The trade can be executed using any payment type available under the Cash Boost Account: Cash, CPF, SRS, or CDP.

Click to access the activity

Other helpful links:

• 💰Join the TB Contra Telegram Group to Get $10 Trading Vouchers Now🎉

• How to open a CBA. How to link your CDP account. Other FAQs on CBA. Cash Boost Account Website.