Nvidia and AMD Under Attack! Are Short Sellers Exposing the AI Bubble or Creating Buying Opportunities?
π¨$NVIDIA(NVDA)$
π¨$Advanced Micro Devices(AMD)$
Comrades, just when investors thought the AI selloff couldn't get more dramatic, another wave of controversy has hit Wall Street.
First Nvidia.
Now AMD.
Short-selling firms are questioning the industry's China exposure, customer financing and the sustainability of enormous AI infrastructure commitments.
And the stock market is reacting violently.
π Nvidia closed November 19 at $145.98, down 3.3%.
π AMD closed at $489.19, down 7.7%.
π AMD then slipped further towards $472.50 after-hours.
But here's what interests me most.
Are short sellers discovering genuine cracks in the AI economy, or are investors allowing fear to overwhelm the fundamentals?
I think the answer is more complicated than either narrative suggests.
And that creates both opportunities and significant risks.
π₯ 1. Three Short-Seller Reports, One Common Theme
The latest controversy didn't begin with AMD.
In May, Culper Research questioned Nvidia's China-related business.
On November 17, Muddy Waters publicly disclosed a short position in Nvidia while raising questions about relationships involving a former senior executive and a Chinese server supply chain.
Then, on November 19, Hunterbrook Media published allegations concerning AMD's China business.
Hunterbrook Capital, its affiliated investment fund, disclosed that it was short AMD.
The latest report alleged that newer AMD firmware appeared in products associated with a Chinese server manufacturer placed on a US export blacklist.
It also questioned AMD's customer financing arrangements and infrastructure commitments.
But here's the critical distinction.
These reports contain allegations and interpretations, not established findings that either company violated export laws.
AMD publicly rejected Hunterbrook's characterisation and said it maintains rigorous compliance with applicable US export controls.
Reuters also stated that it could not independently verify Hunterbrook's findings.
Investors need to examine the evidence without treating accusations as proven facts.
π 2. AMD's 11% Intraday Plunge: What Actually Happened?
AMD's November 19 trading session was particularly revealing.
The stock opened around $542.
It reached an intraday high near $555.
Then the short-seller report appeared.
AMD subsequently plunged to approximately $470.56 before recovering somewhat.
By the close, shares stood at $489.19, down 7.7% from the previous close.
After-hours trading took them towards $472.50.
This distinction matters.
The stock experienced an intraday fall exceeding 11%, but it did not close 11% below the previous day's closing price.
Now consider the bigger picture.
AMD has significant opportunities in AI accelerators and data centre infrastructure.
But the short-seller controversy is forcing investors to consider another risk.
What happens if AI chip companies help finance their customers, only for those customers to reduce spending later?
The concern is that chip suppliers could face weaker demand at the same time they remain exposed to substantial contractual commitments.
However, conditional guarantees, equity investments and ordinary purchase commitments are not interchangeable with immediate cash liabilities.
That's why I wouldn't simply add every headline figure together and call it debt.
βοΈ 3. Nvidia's Bigger Problem: Even Great Earnings Aren't Enough
Now look at Nvidia.
Its latest results were extraordinary.
π° Quarterly revenue: $115.8B
π» Data Center revenue: $107.6B
π Next-quarter revenue guidance: $130B Β±3%
Yet the shares continued declining.
Nvidia has now experienced six consecutive down sessions.
Why?
Because investors are looking beyond headline growth.
They are questioning future gross margins, leadership uncertainty, export-control exposure and the profitability of massive AI infrastructure investment.
Here's my contrarian perspective.
Nvidia doesn't need to lose its technological leadership for its stock valuation to fall.
Investors may simply become unwilling to pay the same earnings multiple while uncertainty rises.
And there is another complication.
If large AI customers are borrowing heavily or relying on complex financing arrangements to expand infrastructure, investors will increasingly ask whether the underlying demand is economically sustainable.
This doesn't mean the AI boom is fake.
But it does mean a strong order book isn't automatically equivalent to high-quality future cash flow.
π§ 4. Can We Trust Short Sellers?
Here's how I approach activist short-selling reports.
I read them carefully.
But I never assume that a short position automatically makes an investigation false.
And I never assume that a detailed report automatically makes its allegations true.
Short sellers have a financial incentive to benefit from falling prices.
That incentive deserves scrutiny.
Muddy Waters' own November 17 disclosure said it intended to begin covering a substantial portion, potentially all, of its Nvidia short position after publication.
So investors should not assume that the firm remains short indefinitely.
However, short sellers can also uncover genuine accounting, governance or financial risks.
The right question isn't whether the author is bullish or bearish. It's whether the evidence withstands independent scrutiny.
My preferred approach is to separate three categories.
β Verified facts, such as reported financial commitments or formal disclosures.
β οΈ Allegations, such as disputed claims about export-control relationships.
π Interpretations, such as predictions that customer financing will eventually create losses.
Confusing these categories is where investors can make expensive mistakes.
π― 5. My NVDA and AMD Prediction: November 20β27
Given the current uncertainty, I lean towards continued volatility rather than an immediate, sustained AI-sector rebound.
Here are my judgment-based scenarios for the coming sessions.
π’ Bull Case: 25%
Nvidia: $155β$165
AMD: $510β$550
Selling pressure eases as investors reassess the short-seller claims.
Buyers regain confidence in AI demand, and semiconductor stocks begin recovering together.
A sustained reclaim of $155 for Nvidia and $500 for AMD would be early positive signals.
π‘ Base Case: 45%
Nvidia: $140β$155
AMD: $455β$510
This is my most likely scenario.
Expect sharp relief rallies, renewed selling and continued debate about export controls, valuations and customer financing.
The market may need more time before investors are comfortable rebuilding significant exposure.
π΄ Bear Case: 30%
Nvidia: $125β$140
AMD: $410β$455
Further negative disclosures, regulatory developments or a broader technology selloff intensify pressure.
AMD could remain particularly volatile given its recent sharp price reversal.
These are subjective scenario probabilities, not statistically validated forecasts or guaranteed price targets.
My prediction? A relief bounce is possible, but a sustainable recovery will require stronger evidence than one or two green trading sessions.
π° 6. My Trading Plan: Where Would I Look for Opportunities?
For Nvidia, I'm watching:
π΄ $145: Immediate decision area
π΄ $140: Next psychological support
π‘ $150β$155: First meaningful recovery zone
π’ $160β$165: Stronger bullish confirmation
For AMD:
π΄ $470: Recent intraday and after-hours support area
π΄ $450: Potential next downside zone
π‘ $490β$500: First recovery battleground
π’ $530: Stronger confirmation of improving momentum
Personally, I wouldn't rush into a large position simply because these stocks have fallen sharply.
I'd watch the first 30β60 minutes of regular trading for evidence of buyers defending support.
A rebound on declining volume wouldn't convince me.
I'd prefer improving market breadth, stronger semiconductor participation and credible company responses to the outstanding allegations.
For existing holders, I would focus on managing exposure rather than allowing the desire to recover losses to dictate decisions.
And I would be especially careful with leveraged positions.
A short-seller report can create a sharp price gap before stop-loss orders have an opportunity to execute.
π‘ 7. My Final Take: Are AI Stocks Being Hunted?
Short sellers are certainly increasing scrutiny of the AI sector.
But I wouldn't describe every share-price decline as manipulation.
Nvidia and AMD are facing genuine investor questions about valuations, export controls, financing structures and the return on enormous AI investments.
Some short-seller claims may prove exaggerated.
Others may expose risks that investors previously overlooked.
What matters is the evidence.
My strongest view is that the AI industry can continue expanding while individual AI stocks undergo painful valuation corrections.
Nvidia may retain its technological leadership.
AMD may continue attracting important customers.
But neither is immune to changing market expectations.
I would rather wait for price stabilisation and improving institutional demand than attempt to catch every falling knife.
Sometimes a market correction creates an opportunity.
Sometimes it reveals that investors were paying too much.
The skill lies in recognising the difference.
Comrades, what do you think?
Are short sellers exposing important risks, or creating an opportunity to accumulate Nvidia and AMD at lower prices?
I am not a financial advisor. Trade wisely, Comrades!
If you find this post interesting, give it wings! πͺ½ Repost and share the insights. Do consider βFollow meβ and get firsthand read of my daily new post. Thank you.
@TigerPM @TigerStars @Daily_Discussion @TigerEvents @Tiger_SG
Disclaimer: Investing carries risk. This is not financial advice. The above content should not be regarded as an offer, recommendation, or solicitation on acquiring or disposing of any financial products, any associated discussions, comments, or posts by author or other users should not be considered as such either. It is solely for general information purpose only, which does not consider your own investment objectives, financial situations or needs. TTM assumes no responsibility or warranty for the accuracy and completeness of the information, investors should do their own research and may seek professional advice before investing.
- 1PCΒ·11-20 22:12Nice Sharing π @Barcode @JC888 @Aqa @DiAngel @Shyon @koolgal @Sherniceθ»ε¬£ 2000LikeReport
